WORKING HOURS

9:00am to 06:30pm

CALL US

+91 11 29945946

MAIL US

info@icif.in

DROPPING THE IDEA OF ISLAMIC BANKING IN INDIA WILL LEAVE MILLIONS SHORTCHANGED

There is an air of finality and inevitability to the Reserve Bank of India’s (RBI) recent decision to rule out introducing Islamic banking in India. It appears that just the presence of the word “Islamic” is reason enough to surmise that the Modi government – and ideological parent Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) – will not be comfortable with the idea of serving up interest-free products guided by Sharia law for Indian banking consumers.

That is a pity, because millions of Indian consumers will be shortchanged.

The RBI – an autonomous, constitutional body – has been taciturn about the reasons behind its decision. Islamic banking is basically a form of finance that rules out receipt and payment of interest and fees. The rules forbid profiting from money lending. So, for instance, Islamic banks buy properties for clients, and then sell them back at a profit, allowing clients to pay back installments. Another route is structuring profit-sharing agreements between the borrower and the bank. Leases and hire purchase are allowed. Guided by the Quran, Islamic banking also does not allow money to be invested in speculative, “non-productive” investments, like gambling, liquor, tobacco and weapons.

While Islamic-friendly products can be found in India’s non-banking finance companies – cooperative societies and chit funds – these are not regulated by the central bank. Recently, cooperative banks with Islamic banking products were set up in Kerala (Cherman Financial Services Ltd) and Maharashtra (Lokmangal Cooperative Bank). There are just a handful of ethical mutual funds in this space and a Shariah-compliant stock index, the BSE TASIS Shariah 50. So, products (a very small number, no doubt) exist to meet the market need in India.

On the face of it, there are two reasons cited by government to disallow Islamic banking. One, there are other vehicles of financial inclusion, like Jan Dhan accounts. So, the argument goes, why should a “secular” banking system tailor-make financial products aimed at one particular community? The second argument meted out is that enabling Islamic banking would require changing laws, rewriting the RBI’s holy books as it were, since interest is the sine qua non of banking. That requires legislative support, which brings us back to the BJP.

The third underlying – and unstated – objection is the fear that Islamic finance will be used to fund terror, or channel terror money. The simple way of looking at this is that Islamic banking is misunderstood. But the reality is a growing suspicion about, among other things, the committee of experts (the Sharia boards and committees) who oversee such banking decisions in the name of faith.

The fact is for some time now representatives of Indian Muslim community – some 180 million strong – have been pushing for such banking products. Globally, it is a $2-trillion industry growing at a double-digit rate. While West Asia and Muslim countries take up a large part of this pie, developed banking systems have also opened up windows to allow such products. In recent years, banking and related Sharia-compliant services have been among the fastest-growing segments of finance in the West. London is a big hub of Islamic banking. Germany and US have limited offerings, but they can be found. According to the BBC, in recent years, banks in Hong Kong, Luxembourg, South Africa and the UK have issued Islamic bonds.

In India, there is an unmet market need for such products. Fewer Muslims in India operate a bank account compared to other religions. At 7.4%, the Muslim community’s share of bank deposits and loans is lower than the national average. Because their religion does not allow them to invest in interest-bearing products, Muslims end up keeping money at home or running the risk of loan sharks and fly-by-night operators that use the cover of NBFCs to hoodwink consumers. Money coming in as remittances from West Asia is also not making it into the banking system.

The Indian financial system is far from secular – the widespread use of the Hindu Undivided Family (HUF), for one, shows that, after all, finance has to be structured around the needs of communities. The legislative changes too are not insurmountable. Some would argue it’s all about coming up with new methods to serve up interest in another garb. For example, current accounts are not interest bearing. Similarly, there’s no harm in experimenting with a window within the existing financial system, as most of the Western world has done. Clearly, the political will is missing.

In any case, when the definition of money and banking is rapidly changing in this age of mobile wallets and booming bitcoins, why can’t Islamic banking come in the category of another product aimed at a niche audience? Painting Islamic banking as antiquated, a financial system from the Middle Ages, as many have done, is driven more by wariness against Islam in the West and, in recent years, in India.

It is hardly a regressive financial system. As David Graeber points out in his brilliant book Debt: The First 5,000 Years, Islam had a positive view towards commerce. As he writes:

“…No Islamic thinker ever treated the honest pursuit of profit as itself intrinsically immoral or inimical to faith. Neither did the prohibitions against usury mitigate against any sense of commerce, or even the development of complex credit instruments.”

At the heart of the economic philosophy is an aversion to price fixing – you see, markets were designed by God to regulate themselves. In fact, the underlying thought resembles in some way Adam Smith’s “invisible hand”. Graeber highlights the interesting fact that Smith used thoughts that were prevalent in medieval Persia. Both Ghazali (1058-1111 AD) and Tusi (1201-1274 AD) use the same argument: no one has seen two dogs exchanging bones.

Consider how Ghazali articulates his view about money: “A thing can be exactly linked to other things if it has no particular special form or feature of its own – for example, a mirror that has no color can reflect all colors. The same is the case with money – it has no purpose of its own, but it serves as a medium for the purpose of exchanging goods.” Taking this thought to its logical conclusion means lending money at interest is wrong – by doing so, money is being used as “an end in itself”.

Clearly, the Indian financial establishment has sensed the need for Islamic banking. Earlier RBI governors and the UPA government had seriously considered the idea of introducing such products in India in a phased manner. Now, the most recent push – by former RBI governor Raghuram Rajan in November 2016 – has been snuffed out. What is all the more disquieting is the quiet acceptance of this discriminatory move by the government that purports to speak for the Hindus.

Who will speak for those parked deep inside India’s financial ghettos?

Sunit Arora is a Delhi-based journalist and former managing editor at Outlook magazine.

thewire.in/214561/islamic-banking-rbi/

Posted Date : 18 January 2018

News Updates

  • INT’L ZAKAT CONFERENCE KERALA CATERS HOPE FOR CREATIVE ZAKAT SYSTEM IN INDIA

    By HABEEB RAHMAN CP The International Zakat Conference, organised by Baithuzzakath Kerala, concludes in Cochin with the new hope for the effective zakat management in the country. More than 250 high-profile delegates from various parts of the country and other nations participated in the conference...

    Read More
  • ZAKAT THE SOURCE OF SOCIAL UPLIFTMENT AND ECONOMIC EMPOWERMENT

    Dr. Rahmatullah Abdul Ahad dwells upon how Zakat can be a source of social upliftment and economic empowerment. Poverty, which indicates the absence of material means, is rampant in all the states of India irrespective of caste and clan wise composition of the society. The consequence is sufferings...

    Read More
  • ISLAMIC BANKING IN J&K: HC GIVES FINANCE MINISTRY, RBI TWO MORE WEEKS TO RESPOND

    The Forum also seeks direction to the J&K Bank to take immediate steps for opening of Shariah-compliant windows to accomplish the objective of mass level participation in Shariah Banking. The High Court on Tuesday granted two more weeks to the Union Finance Ministry, Reserve Bank of Ind...

    Read More
  • Online admission for second batch of MBA Insurance 2018 - 2020 at Jamia Hamdard

    Online admission for second batch of MBA Insurance 2018 - 2020 at Jamia Hamdard, Deemed University, New Delhi has started. The link is https://admissions. jamiahamdard.edu This insurance course is being run by Jamia Hamdard in collaboration with Asean Institute of Insurance & Risk M...

    Read More
  • ISLAMIC FINANCE EMBRACING SMALL, MEDIUM ENTERPRISES

    There is an ongoing trend in countries with Islamic finance ecosystems of discovering the importance of small and medium enterprises (SMEs) for economic well-being and growth.  Traditionally, SMEs have not played a substantial role in oil-rich Middle Eastern countries where the economy used ...

    Read More
  • INDONESIA PRESIDENT OPTIMISTIC ON GROWTH OF FUNDS FOR MICRO WAKAF BANKS

    Banten, March 14 -- President Joko Widodo (Jokowi) is optimistic that several people would come forward to donate funds to micro 'wakaf' banks in Indonesia, thereby encouraging the development of the micro business sector. "We will push donors as much as possible. I am certain many people want...

    Read More
  • PIL PRAYS FOR ISLAMIC BANKING IN J&K

    High Court Issues Notices; Asks Union Finance Ministry, RBI, J&K Bank, J&K Government To Respond D A RASHID Srinagar, Publish Date: Mar 20 2018 The High Court on Monday asked Union Finance Ministry, Reserve Bank of India, Jammu and Kashmir Government and Jammu and Kashmir Bank to respond t...

    Read More