9:00am to 06:30pm


+91 11 29945946


Economic Times : Shariah-compliant financial products will only advance a retrograde political agenda

Shariah-compliant financial products will only advance a retrograde political agenda

December 4, 2014, 5:09 AM IST Economic Times in ET Commentary | Business, Companies,Economy, Edit Page, Finance, India, Markets, Times View | ET

By Sadanand Dhume

Should the secular Indian state advance the religious norms enshrined in Islamic shariah law? This is the question raised by an ill-advised move by SBI Funds Management to start an Islamic mutual fund called the SBI Shariah Equity Fund. The fund, whose scheduled launch this week has reportedly been deferred, will be benchmarked to the S&P BSE 500 Shariah Index. Managers will pick stocks guided by a shariah board, whose responsibilities include procuring appropriate fatwas, or religious edicts, for permissible investments.

To understand why this is a terrible idea, go back to the roots of modern Islamic finance. First proposed in pre-Partition India by Jamaat-e-Islami founder Abul Ala Maududi (1903-79), shariah-compliant financial practices are part of a larger Islamist project to order every aspect of the state and society by the medieval norms enshrined in shariah law. According to Duke University’s Professor Timur Kuran, Maududi’s goal was not to foster prosperity in his community, but to underscore the idea that “to be a Muslim is to live differently”.

Islamic finance ostensibly hinges on three principles: a ban on interest, a wealth tax (zakat) and honesty in business. More broadly, it applies religious norms to business decisions. Shariah-compliant funds, for instance, will not invest in companies whose practices are frowned upon by Islam, such as pig farms or banks that charge interest.

Historically, Maududi’s idea languished for decades before being given a boost by Saudi oil wealth in the 1970s. Since then Islamic finance has grown steadily. Standard and Poor’s estimates that shariah-compliant assets are worth about $1.4 trillion worldwide, the vast majority in Muslim-majority countries such as Saudi Arabia, Pakistan and Malaysia.

Maududi envisioned Islamic finance as accomplishing three goals: minimising Muslim interaction with non-Muslims, deepening the transnational identity of the community of believers, or ummah, and injecting Islam into every aspect of daily life. Over the years, Islamist groups worldwide, including the Muslim Brotherhood in the Arab world and the Jamaat-e-Islami in the Indian subcontinent, have worked tirelessly to advance these objectives. It’s no coincidence that Islamic finance has grown along with a broader swing in the Muslim world away from secularism and toward literalist interpretations of Islam.


What does all this mean for India? Simply put, policymakers need to gauge products such as the new SBI fund not merely in narrow financial terms, but in terms of their larger implications.

They can start by asking some basic questions. Should state-owned institutions in an avowedly secular republic advance Islamist political goals? Is India better served by integrating its 150-million strong Muslim population into the financial mainstream, or by ghettoising it in the economic equivalents of Ahmedabad’s Juhapura or Thane’s Bhiwandi? Does the new fund inch India closer toward accepting Islamic banking, which it has so far avoided?

The answers ought to be self-evident. That the questions were apparently not asked highlights a certain naiveté at the heart of India’s financial establishment. Last year, during the waning days of D Subbarao’s tenure as RBI governor, the central bank set a poor precedent by granting a licence to a non-banking finance company in Kerala based on shariah principles. The new SBI fund would further strengthen the dubious principle of mixing religion and finance. It would also make India only the second non-Islamic country (after Britain) with a stateowned bank that offers a shariahcompliant fund.

For the BJP-led government, the shariah-based fund ought to be a litmus test. In the 1990s, the BJP rose to prominence in part by critiquing the Congress’ tendency to equate secularism with pandering to the most orthodox elements in Islamic society. At its heart, stripped of financial complexities, this is what the proposed new fund represents.

Indeed, when given a choice, ordinary Muslims worldwide show no special affinity for shariah-based financial products. Most are happy to use regular banks that pay interest. Moreover, pious Indian Muslims already have the option to channel their investments through shariahcompliant private funds such as the Tata Ethical Fund. There’s no reason for state-owned institutions to follow.


More broadly, instead of promoting Maududi’s divisive vision, India ought to do exactly the opposite. Rather than minimise Muslim exposure to regular financial instruments, India should encourage more Muslims to enter the financial mainstream.

And instead of spawning financial products that appeal to religious identity, state-owned banks should simply treat Muslims like they treat all other Indians. Indeed, if properly implemented, the prime minister’s ambitious financial inclusion plan, the Jan Dhan Yojana, could offer a template of sorts by increasing the number of Muslims with bank accounts.

For now, though, the ball is in SBI Fund Management’s court. If it’s wise, it will give the SBI Shariah Equity Fund a quiet burial and move on to more sensible projects. The last thing India needs is clueless bankers who strengthen a dangerous ideology without understanding the consequences.

The writer is a resident fellow at the American Enterprise Institute, Washington, DC

Posted Date : 29 December 2014

News Updates


    India is on track to overtake the UK to become the world’s fifth-largest economy in 2018, according to data and forecasts from the IMF. Soon it will trail only Germany and the ‘big three’ – the US, China and Japan. However, the Indian banking system is gasping for breath with...

    Read More
  • Islamic Development Bank seeks tie-ups for infrastructure investments

    Islamic Development Bank exploring joint opportunities with other multilateral development banks to invest in India’s infrastructure sector Tue, Jun 26 2018 Utpal Bhaskar Mumbai: Islamic Development Bank Group, one of the largest lenders to Muslim countries, is interested in exploring joint...

    Read More

          Trying to bring Islamic banking to India   Though Muslims are a minority in India and are generally less affluent than Hindus, in sheer numbers they make India the second largest Muslim nation in the world. Cumulatively, their investment power is tremendous and rep...

    Read More

      Criminal for our education sector to ignore it any longer Dr Mehboob Makhdoomi Srinagar | Posted : Jun 3 2018 The International Monetary Fund (IMF) has finally incorporated Islamic Finance into its financial sector assessments beginning January 1, 2019, calling Islamic Finance ...

    Read More
  • Islamic Finance Muslims in India develop mutual health insurance scheme as alternative to takaful

    Islamic finance pioneers and like-minded community leaders in India have come together to introduce an alternative product to formal takaful, which doesn’t exist in the country. A not-for-profit health assurance scheme, called Uplift Mutuals Biradaree, started in April this year at two of M...

    Read More

    By HABEEB RAHMAN CP The International Zakat Conference, organised by Baithuzzakath Kerala, concludes in Cochin with the new hope for the effective zakat management in the country. More than 250 high-profile delegates from various parts of the country and other nations participated in the conference...

    Read More

    Dr. Rahmatullah Abdul Ahad dwells upon how Zakat can be a source of social upliftment and economic empowerment. Poverty, which indicates the absence of material means, is rampant in all the states of India irrespective of caste and clan wise composition of the society. The consequence is sufferings...

    Read More